It is rare to have a Kolbe Index result change significantly upon retake. Studies show this happens less than 12% of the time, unless the original result shows “Transition,” or the temporary inability to report how you naturally take action.
Results that do change are generally because a person desires a different one for some reason. Research shows that the first result is the most accurate because it is less influenced by such desires.
If you take the Kolbe A Index a second time because of a Transition result, the second (if it does not also show Transition) will be the truer picture of your natural abilities.
Don’t be alarmed. Most of us go through periods just like this from time to time. The result indicates that you are not able to work in a way that is natural for you. You’ve adopted methods to satisfy others’ expectations (because of professional or perhaps personal change), and you don’t give yourself permission to do things your way. This can be stressful; re-examination of your methods and motives is in order. Once the underlying conditions leading to this conflict are gone, a retest should give you a reliable and valuable assessment of your natural talents. To retake a Kolbe A Index after receiving a Transition result, you should call us at (602) 840-9770, for a free retake. Please provide the name of the person who completed the Index and the username.
We certainly cannot stop people from trying to manipulate their result. However, one of the strengths of the Kolbe Index result is that it picks up the inconsistencies which are highly likely to occur when a person does not answer truthfully. It is extremely difficult to select an answer that would cause you to perform less effectively in an attempt to “look better.” If people believe that getting a job, for instance, requires that they answer contrary to who they are, they would also have to perform against their grain should they get the job. Therefore, this inappropriate effort in taking the Kolbe Index, when detected by our algorithms, results in prospective employers receiving a warning that the job candidate needs to retake the Index before being considered for employment. An individual result, in these situations, indicates the inconsistencies and lack of ability to predict performance based upon them. This has proven to be valuable information in the selection process, for both employers and employees. If your Index result indicates Transition, you can order a CD or audio download with Kathy Kolbe discussing Transition results.
No, not at all. Your answers will be just as accurate whether you compete the Index at home, work, school, on vacation or in a sauna.
The Predictive Index and Myers-Briggs assessments measure traits falling within the affective (feeling) part of the mind — entirely different qualities than the Kolbe (which is a measure of the conative, doing, domain), so they do not provide redundant information. Assessment tools for the affective domain and the Kolbe Index identify entirely different human characteristics. If the instrument asks questions related to any of the following, it will gather information related to the affective domain:
An accurate prediction of affective behavior will describe what a person WANTS or WISHES would happen. Knowing that desires can change over time, authors Myers and Briggs recognized that their instrument (the MBTI) ought not to be used for selection. Such instruments generally have around 44% test-retest reliability.
An accurate prediction of conative behavior will describe how a person naturally takes action when striving. Instincts are innate and do not change over time, so a valid assessment of this domain would have much greater reliability. The Kolbe A Index has proven the reliability of over 90%, making it the most reliable selection tool on the market today.
Conative and affective tools can both play important roles in team success. Kolbe WAREwithal® software predicts how people will act, react and interact. It doesn’t identify whom they want to be with, or whether they approve of behaviors or value similar attributes; these are affective issues. The Predictive Index can help explain why people like or dislike each other. The Kolbe Index explains why they either will or will not get results if those people work together.